Why reviews decide who gets the call
Reviews do two jobs at once. To a patient choosing between two practices, a profile with forty recent reviews that answer real questions beats one with six from three years ago, every time; people read them the way they would ask a neighbour. To Google, the count, the recency and the words inside reviews are a large part of how prominent a business looks, which decides who appears in the map pack for “podiatrist near me”.
The gap between practices with reviews and practices without is rarely a gap in care. It is a gap in asking.
The moment that matters
A patient who has just had a good visit is willing to say so for about a day. After that, life happens. Every review system that works is built on catching that day, every time, without the front desk having to remember. A request on the same evening, with a link that opens the review box directly, gets a response rate that a request a week later never will.
This is also why asking in person at checkout underperforms: the patient agrees, walks out, and the moment passes before they find your listing on their phone.
How to ask
Send it by text, and by email if you have it. A short message from the practice, in the practice’s voice, the same evening as the visit. One link, straight to the Google review box (Google gives every Business Profile a short share link for this). No account to create, no listing to search for.
Keep the words simple. Something like: “Thank you for visiting Example Podiatry today. If you have a minute, a Google review helps other patients find us: [link]. Thank you, the Example team.” No pressure, no incentive, no suggestion of what to write.
Ask everyone. Not just the patients you think were happy. Picking who to ask is called review gating and it is against Google’s policy; it is also how a practice ends up with a suspiciously perfect profile that patients distrust.
Make it automatic. A tool connected to the schedule, or a daily list at close of business. If it depends on someone remembering, it stops within a month.
What Google forbids
No incentives: no discounts, gift cards or entries in a draw for a review. No gating: no filtering patients by how the visit went before deciding who to ask. No writing reviews yourself, having staff write them, or buying them. No asking for reviews in bulk from a list of people who did not have a recent visit. Any of these can get a profile suspended, and a suspended profile disappears from the map entirely.
The rules are not a burden if you follow the simple method above, because the simple method is also the one that works.
Replying without breaching privacy
Reply to every review, including the difficult ones. A profile where the owner answers reads as a business that is paying attention, and Google treats engagement the same way. For a medical practice, though, a reply must never confirm that the reviewer was a patient, never mention their visit, their condition or their treatment, and never argue the medical facts.
A safe shape for a difficult one: “Thank you for taking the time to write. We take every comment seriously and would welcome the chance to talk it through directly; please call the office at [number] and ask for [name].” It acknowledges, it invites a conversation, and it gives nothing away. A safe shape for a good one: “Thank you for the kind words. We are glad to have been able to help.” Short, warm, and silent about what was done.
Reviews that clearly break Google’s policies (spam, a competitor, someone who was never a customer) can be reported. Most stay. The fix for an unfair review is twenty fair ones.
Put the reviews to work
Show the best ones on your site, on the pages that convert, with the source named and a link to the profile. Quote them in a new-patient email. Read them monthly for what people praise and what they complain about; the complaints are a free audit of the front desk and the parking.
If you would rather not run this yourself, it is what our review generation service does: the timed asks, the drafted replies, the reviews on your site, and a line in the monthly report for the count and the trend. Start with the free website audit, which includes a look at your profile, or call (561) 324-1658.
Published 11 November 2026 · by Design of Man. Educational, not legal, medical or financial advice.